Greensburg Daily News, Greensburg, IN


April 3, 2013

‘Room 237’ for Kubrick, ‘Shining’ fans only

Greensburg — We spurn Hollywood’s latest big releases and instead watched the documentary Room 237 (NR), which is currently available from several on-demand cable/ satellite providers. T

he film explores five wildly different theories behind the meaning of Stanley Kubrick’s 1980 film The Shining. Rodney Ascher directs.

Andy: The premise of Room 237 — the idea that Stanley Kubrick was not actually adapting Stephen King’s novel, but only using it as a vehicle to communicate a multi-layered allegory — is great fun for literary criticism nerds and fans of The Shining. At the same time, if you do not fall into one of or both of those categories, Room 237 will come across as some combination of boring and depressingly paranoid. As somebody who falls into both of those categories, I found the movie to be great fun, even if it is flawed.

Ryan: I think it should also be said of what Room 237 isn’t: This is not a documentary on the making of The Shining, nor is it a documentary on the meaning of The Shining as viewed through the scope of it being horror film. Room 237 is an exercise in extreme critical thought that at times tows the line between deep critical thinking and conspiratorial gibberish. If one is a fan of film criticism, then Room 237 offers some fascinating ideas in what Kubrick really meant to express with his adaptation of The Shining (as theorized by these five Shining-enthusiasts). But it’s also true that one has to take much of what the film says with a grain of salt. One of the arguments in the film is that The Shining is Kubrick’s apology for faking the Apollo 11 moon landing footage back in 1969. Most reasonable people would find fault in that conspiracy (and I did as well) but it is fascinating to witness the passion and certainty of the narrator when he’s making his case. You might not buy what these people are selling but you are still fascinated by their thought processes.

Andy: The theories expressed in the documentary range from very believable (it’s really about the Holocaust, or genocide of Native Americans), to downright nutty (it’s a confession about Kubrick faking the moon landing). What’s noteworthy is that all of these critics seem to fully believe that they have cracked the secret code of the movie. The takeaway as an impartial viewer becomes a certainty that there is a purposeful, rich subtext to the film that lends itself to all sorts of meanings depending on the viewer. In other words, this documentary convinces me of nothing beyond the fact that The Shining is a much richer piece of art than I had originally thought, and I already was fond of the movie.

Ryan: From a technical aspect, Room 237’s composition is also a mixed bag. The film crosscuts scenes not just from The Shining but from other Kubrick films as well (and also from some other random films too). Sometimes this is effective — as it shows Kubrick’s film genius — but it’s also distracting when other random films by other directors are just arbitrarily spliced into the documentary’s narrative.  You also never see these theorists on camera, thus adding a layer of mystery to the whole production, which I guess in the long run, might actually help the film out. But consequently one never sees these people challenged with regard to their theories. I would have liked to have seen the narrator or filmmaker offer some resistance to these out-of-the-norm hypotheses.

Andy: For all of the insight, wackiness, and deeply interesting subject matter in Room 237, it must be noted that the construction of the documentary is quite odd. As Ryan mentions, the film never shows the critics who are voicing over the explanations of their theories, instead illustrating points with clips from The Shining (which is very effective), other Kubrick films (which does not always work well) and other random films (which is sometimes just silly). It also gets pretty confusing pretty quickly if you are not familiar with The Shining, or you are not in tune with the odd documentary style. The subject is interesting enough that the film works, but there are clear shortcomings.

Not many directors could have inspired such an uncanny documentary. Let’s face it. Stanley Kubrick is a cinematic genius and one of the greatest directors of all-time, but he was also a very private and reclusive individual. When one couples all of that together in this media age, some people are going to come up with some pretty wild ideas. Room 237 labors along at times, but it’s a hard film to forget.  Final grade:  B-.


Text Only
  • ent-gb082114-movie wolf pic 'Under the Skin' is too much art for art's sake FROM THE DEN AT HOME -- “Under the Skin” is the single, most bizarre film I’ve seen in 2014.It stars Scarlett Johansson as an alien from an unnamed planet and star system, and is classified in critical circles as an “art” film. Had I known that fact

    August 21, 2014 1 Photo

  • ent-gb082114-Movie boys pic Inventive and mysterious, "The One I Love" is worth seeking This week we ignore the latest batch of new releases out of Hollywood and instead turn our focus to the indie dramedy, The One I Love (R). In the film, Mark Duplass and Elisabeth Moss star as a married couple whose marriage is on the rocks. Attemptin

    August 21, 2014 1 Photo

  • New arrivals at the library eBooksBefore the End, After the Beginning: Stories by Gilb, DagobertoThe Autumn Bride: Chance Sisters Series, Book 1 by Gracie, AnneMallets Aforethought: Home Repair is Homicide Mystery Series, Book 7 by Graves, SarahUnhinged: Home Repair is Homicide

    August 16, 2014

  • "The Expendables 3" movie poster Movie preview: “The Expendables 3”

    Plot: Commander Barney augments his team with new blood as this latest mission becomes a clash of classic old-school style versus high-tech expertise in the Expendables’ most personal battle yet.

    August 14, 2014 1 Photo

  • "The Giver" movie poster Movie preview: “The Giver”

    Plot: In a seemingly perfect future community, without war, pain, suffering, differences or choice, a young man discovers the sinister secrets that hold his fragile society together after being selected to join the Giver.

    August 14, 2014 1 Photo

  • "Let's Be Cops" movie poster Movie preview: “Let’s Be Cops”

    Plot: Two struggling pals dress as police officers for a costume party and become neighborhood sensations. But when these newly-minted “heroes” get tangled in a real life web of mobsters and dirty detectives, they must put their fake badges on the line.

    August 14, 2014 1 Photo

  • ent-gb081414-Movie Boys pic 'A Most Wanted Man' This week we caught the spy-thriller A Most Wanted Man (R). Philip Seymour Hoffman stars as a German outsider spy who is attempting to facilitate the capture of high ranking terrorists, using a young Chechen muslim played by Grigoriy Dobrygin. Based

    August 14, 2014 1 Photo

  • ent-gb081414-Movie Wolf pic 'Noah' unbiblical and without charm FROM THE DEN AT HOME — The King James Bible meets J.R.R. Tolkien in Director Darren Aronofsky’s “Noah,” a movie that once more leaves me wondering what critics saw that I didn’t.To be sure, critics didn’t quite go crazy with praise for this film; a f

    August 14, 2014 1 Photo

  • ent-gb081314-new at library pic New arrivals at library New items at the Greensburg-Decatur County Library can be found and reserved at BiographiesFierce Patriot by O’Connell, Robert LCookbooksWild Fish & Game Cookbook by Manikowski, JohnFantasy / Sci-FiThe House of

    August 14, 2014 1 Photo

  • Warning: A blizzard is here! Indulge with a Blizzard® Treat today, Aug. 14, and Dairy Queen® will donate $1 or more to Riley Hospital for Children at Indiana University Health. Approximately 150 Indiana Dairy Queen locations will participate in the ninth annual Dairy Queen Mirac

    August 14, 2014