Greensburg Daily News, Greensburg, IN


September 12, 2013

Lee Daniels' "The Butler," earnest yet muted

Although it’s been out for several weeks, Lee Daniels’s “The Butler” (PG-13) continues to perform at the box-office. In the film, Forest Whitaker stars as a plantation orphan who works his way up to being a butler at the White House. Oprah Winfrey, Cuba Gooding Jr., David Oyelowo and Lenny Kravitz costar in the film. Lee Daines directs.

Andy: “The Butler” is a very ambitious piece of historical fiction that, unfortunately, falls well short of its ambition. First of all, it begins with the obligatory, “Inspired by a true story,” which means it’s fiction that happens to be based on a real guy. This becomes clear almost immediately in how the historical events play out in neat little segments that the main characters always happen to be present for, as well as the superficial way the film handles many of the historical (and personal) events the film depicts.

Ryan: There’s no question that “The Butler” has that Forest Gump vibe where seemingly ordinary people fall upon historical moments around extraordinary people. The film’s narrative follows that same template. But as Andy alludes too, “The Butler” falls short in being the great film it aspires to be. It’s seemingly entertaining on a superficial level and that’s the best compliment I can give it.

Andy: The biggest shortcoming of “The Butler” is that it presents so much of the action in a way that seems like it was made for a movie. When a film chooses to delve into a complex and violent event such as the civil rights movement, there is a responsibility to create that reality in a way that takes the viewer to that time and place. “The Butler” tries to make it personal by placing one of the characters at many of the most relevant events of the civil rights movement. The device backfires, as it ends up feeling contrived, which serves to minimize these important historical developments.

Text Only
  • nws-gb072914 Casa logo CASA sought for "Jennifer" and "Erica" In order to illustrate and bring awareness to the need for Court Appointed Special Advocate (CASA) volunteers in our local community, Advocates for Children will be regularly highlighting one case which is currently on our waiting list. Identifying i

    July 29, 2014 1 Photo

  • nws-gb072914-Self defense pic Smith Martial Arts to hold women’s self-defense class GREENSBURG – It’s an unfortunate fact that women need to know how to protect themselves in today’s society.While it is a comforting thought to believe that someone will help if a woman should find herself in a dangerous situation, there may not alway

    July 29, 2014 1 Photo

  • nws-gb072914-back to school photo 300 students get backpacks, encouragement at Back to School Bash GREENSBURG — With face painting, free hair cuts and backpacks, about 300 local students received some proper primping to help them get over the disappointment that school will begin again next week.About 30 businesses and organizations participated

    July 29, 2014 1 Photo

  • nws-gb072914-devin parson ride pic 2 Ride carries memory of slain boy GREENSBURG – Threatening skies early Saturday morning didn’t dampen or put a damper on the droves that turned out to take part in this year’s annual Devin Lee Parsons “Never Be Forgotten” Memorial Motorcycle Ride.Approximately 55 motorcycles left the

    July 29, 2014 2 Photos

  • nws-gb072914-ymca 100 gala pic03 Local YMCA celebrates 100th anniversary with Gala GREENSBURG — A summer of centennial revelry culminated Saturday night at the Decatur County Family YMCA with the Celebration 100 Gala.Attendees from around the community joined the Y Board of Directors in reminiscing about the local YMCA’s century-lo

    July 29, 2014 3 Photos

  • Family Clothes Closet summer opening approaches WESTPORT – Since 2008, the Family Clothes Closet has opened twice a year to assist local families by providing free clothing for the whole family.Through the combined effort of 24 area churches, five local organizations and many individuals, entire f

    July 29, 2014

  • nws-gb072914-auditor selection pic Chadwell selected as new county auditor GREENSBURG – A group of 16 Republican precinct committee members selected current Decatur County Clerk Janet Chadwell for the vacant County Auditor office during a special caucus at party headquarters Saturday morning.Chadwell, who previously served

    July 29, 2014 1 Photo

  • No confirmation of Philly papal visit PHILADELPHIA (AP) - Whether Pope Francis will visit Philadelphia during a major gathering of the world’s Roman Catholics remained a matter of speculation Friday after the archdiocese said a report he would attend should not be considered confirmation

    July 26, 2014

  • Islamic State destroys Jonah's Tomb in Mosul BAGHDAD (AP) — As Iraq selected a new president, Islamic militants blew up a revered Muslim shrine in Mosul traditionally said to be the burial place of the Prophet Jonah, several residents of the city told The Associated Press.The militants first or

    July 26, 2014

  • Police search Gary for tiger on the loose GARY, Ind. (AP) — Gary police searched the northwest Indiana city for a tiger after receiving several reports of a big cat on the loose.The reports began shortly before midnight Thursday and alleged sightings continued into Friday morning. Officers i

    July 26, 2014